Some folks have pointed out great reviews I didn't like to. What's my excuse for missing them? Well, I've been really busy playing Gears of War working on CES (to which some of you are going, so I'm hoping we can meet up).
First off, MakeYouGoHmm's TDavid** posted a story back in Nov: "Here’s what critics are missing about Zune." He writes:
I’ve been extremely critical of Microsoft in the past on a number of fronts and have absolutely zero problem criticizing them, but instead of being just another lemming rolling out the Microsoft sucks line, I actually went to the store and bought the Zune on launch day and kept an open mind about the device. Sure, I couldn’t help thinking I was going to take it home and be tortured by how poorly the device and software worked, but to summarize in three words what I found?
I liked it. (full story)
Stepping back for a second and looking at the whole online landscape, this is interesting. It seems like there's a meta-story going on about Zune not being objectively or thoroughly reviewed - both by bloggers and mainstream. DVD John points it out, too. Yes, of course I have a bias, working on the Zune team and all ;).
A few days ago, ZDNet's Matthew Miller posted a story about Zune, three weeks later. While other ZDNet writers's don't love Zune, Matthew points out why he likes his Zune player more: subscription option, navigation, and scratch-resistant-ness.
Palmer from Mindsplice posts a comparison of Zune to iPod, using the following scale:
Zune excels in this area.
Zune adds a feature over iPod.
Zune is comparable to iPod in this area.
Zune is inferior in this area.
Zune lacks a feature of iPod.
Limitation of a Zune feature that iPod lacks.
Last but certainly not less-than-awesome: our buddy Woody (what's up Woody! High-five!) over at 'Corps lists out some problems he's been personally having with Zune.
**And again to head off the iFanboy astroturfing accusation, noone from Microsoft, including me, has ever contacted out to TDavid, which he notes in his comment to my post, and again in his own follow-up post:
Just so it’s clear here and to clearly refute the bizarre, unfounded astroturfing accusation: I don’t know anybody who works on the Zune team.
Let me change that now, btw. TDavid! Hello! I'm Cesar Menendez!